Back Louisiana for Christmas,'' Noelle Collins (Mitchell) has big plans to reestablish town's live nativity, a beloved heritage her late mum used to place on. Matters become complicated, however, when Noelle incurs her high school sweetheart, Nick Russell (Colletti), a rising baseball star also back home due to a recent accident. Still setting the burn out of their senior year break up their lives are pushed together even further when they learn a fascination is shared by their parents and want to become more than just friends. When things start to fall apart with the nativity, Noelle and Nick reluctantly team up to pull the show and wind up growing close, uncovering a royal love for one another as well as also the joy of Christmas that both never really faded away.